
Montale

Vilhelm
Moon Aoud
Smoke Show
Only in Moon Aoud
Only in Smoke Show
Shared character
Both fragrances contain rose, vetiver, leather, saffron and oud/agarwood, and they share a woody overall accord. No fragrance family is listed for either.
How they differ
Moon Aoud adds sandalwood, amber and patchouli to the shared rose‑vetiver‑leather‑saffron‑oud base and introduces an ambery (oriental) accord. Smoke Show adds cedarwood and pink pepper and its only exclusive accord is leather, giving it a sharper, more aromatic‑leather focus.
Who each suits
Moon Aoud will likely appeal to wearers who favor warm, ambery, oriental‑type compositions with a focus on sandalwood, amber and patchouli. Smoke Show will likely suit wearers who prefer a fresher, spicier profile highlighted by cedarwood, pink pepper and a pronounced leather accord.